Monday, March 18, 2024

Sex and Gender in Schools

 Starting this blog post reminiscing about my summer job rounding up sheep for castration might not be an obvious connection. But hear me out. 

I grew up in rural New Zealand. Talking about sex and gender was not a thing one did, and I was as oblivious to the world of the LGBTQ community as it was possible to be. I was a girl, I was happy to be called "she", and when the teacher began the school day with "Hello boys and girls" I never felt uncomfortable or excluded by that greeting. 

However, in the summer, I worked on farms and orchards to earn money, and one summer I helped with "Docking". Docking is when the young lambs are rounded up, and one by one a rubber band is put over their tail and male genital organs. The band restricts blood flow and both the tail and genitals fall off over time. This prevents fly-blight in the tail area and unwanted pregnancies in the herd. It is a standard process for all sheep farmers in New Zealand and it was a long hot day in the sun for the teen workers helping the farm hands. During the day, the workers casually showed me when a lamb appeared with 2 visible sex organs. On the farm, they called them "muftis", but they would have been called hermaphrodites if a veterinarian was present. It was a point of interest, and a new thing to show the teenagers, but not uncommon.


I bring this up, because I grew up with a point of reference to biological differences. Sure there are boys and girls, but sometimes nature gives you something a little different. And it is okay. Our article from RIDE shares that "it is estimated that 1 in 2000 babies is born with biological characteristics of both sexes or of neither sex entirely". As teachers, educators, parents and community members, it is our responsibility to make sure that all students are a right to a "Free and Appropriate Public Education", even the ones that don't fit nicely into societies basic categories. The guidance from RIDE focuses on highlighting the vulnerability of Transgender and Gender Non-conforming youth, and asserting their right to attend a school they feel safe in. 

The article "Queering Our Schools" echoed Johnson's plea to "Name It". "The cornerstone of nurturing classrooms is community...Community is built by working through differences not sweeping them under the rug". Like the communities pushing towards a more multicultural education, LGTBQ advocates want more representation across curriculum. They suggest that traditional activities like "Father's Day/Mother's Day/Family Tree" may need re-imagining. I recently experienced the difficulty a "Daddy Daughter" dance can bring. One of my daughter's friends did not have a male role model to bring for a variety of reasons - none of which were her fault or under her control. We welcomed her into our family group, but she had weeks of agonizing over something that excluded her by its very title, through no fault of her own. 

Keeping our schools open and welcoming to all students should be an ongoing priority. Sometimes it is as easy as changing the name of an activity, or making sure the family tree has a larger number of branches. Sometimes it involves adults re-learning something they thought they already knew. While the New Zealand docking season is over for the year, and a little hard to access from New England, maybe watching a TED talk about biological differences might help open your brain to what some students feel every day. 

"I am different." 

"Where do I fit?"

"Will they still like me if they know ME?"

Maybe understanding more, will help create that community that works through differences instead of sweeping them under the rug. 

TED talk here


Monday, March 4, 2024

The Teach Out Proposal

 Text Selection

The texts that have stayed with me the most have been Lisa Delpit's "Cultural Conflict in the Classroom" and Richard Rodriquez's "Aria". I appreciated the acknowledgement of real world realities instead of  being hyper focused on a fictional world view that doesn't exist. Yes, it would be great if every student's culture and language was of equal value in the world we live and work in, but the reality is that every country has it's dominant culture, standards and codes. As Rodriquez learned, his success was dependent on his ability to assimilate into that dominant culture.

Sharing

I teach at a charter school that pulls people from all over Rhode Island. We have students from Providence, South and North Kingstown, Coventry and others. A big focus of mine, as a music teacher, is to create a community feeling for all students, regardless of how far away they have come from. Some students are with us from Kindergarten, others transfer at higher grade levels, but I always want students to feel welcomed and valued in our community. I was the 4th music teacher here in 4 years, and I realized that I needed to establish MY dominant culture and expectations when I started. The students and I had very different ideas about what was appropriate in the classroom. With these ideas in mind, I would like to create a Teach Out proposal for elementary students to learn about classroom expectations and codes, specifically music class codes. 



Format

I would like this activity to be a small group discussion/art project/roleplay scenario. I have an idea in mind that I would create some fictional pirates that are used to different behaviors and language. Those behaviors are fine when they are on their pirate ship, but we have to teach them the rules for music class so they can learn, so they don't disrupt other students learning and so we can have an enjoyable learning community. I'd like to have these pirates also teach us a pirate song so we can learn about their culture, even as we teach the pirates about our music class culture. The Wellerman is a popular sea shanty, and this video shows the singer using his guitar as a drum (which is NOT allowed in class, and a great way to talk about different behaviors in different spaces.)



Teach Out Project Slides

Teach Out Project Slides